For years, my neighbor Denise had a habit of borrowing things and returning them as though someone else would always deal with the consequences.
I tried to overlook it.
A stained dish wasn’t worth an argument. A late return wasn’t worth damaging a neighborhood relationship. Even missing accessories were easier to replace than to fight about.
Then she borrowed something I couldn’t simply replace.
It was my mother’s cream-colored KitchenAid mixer, purchased in 1989.
When Denise returned it, the machine was covered in dried batter, the controls were dirty, and the mixer no longer worked.
She had an explanation.
I wasn’t convinced.
She Said the Mixer Was Simply Old
When I asked Denise what had happened, she suggested that the mixer had probably worn out because of its age.
There was one problem.
The damage didn’t look like ordinary wear from decades of careful use.
The machine appeared to have been overloaded and kept running while struggling.
I could have argued with her.
Instead, I took it to Greg, a repair professional familiar with older appliances.
His estimate stopped the conversation in its tracks:
$347 to repair it.
For Denise, it was an old kitchen appliance.
For me, it was something my mother had used for birthdays, holidays, family gatherings, and ordinary afternoons.
The mixer had survived for decades because someone had taken care of it.
Now it needed a $347 repair after one borrowing.
Denise Didn’t Think She Owed Me Anything
I showed Denise the repair estimate.
She refused to pay.
Her reasoning was that when you borrow something, you have to accept the possibility that it might break.
I understood the possibility.
What I couldn’t accept was the idea that someone could damage another person’s property through careless use and simply call the result unavoidable.
Still, I didn’t want a neighborhood feud.
So I stopped arguing.
Instead, I changed the rules.
Then Denise Needed My Things Again
Keep reading…